Hasbro is to release a new Mr. Potato-Head doll called "Darth Tater" --inspired by the Star Wars series. Below, suggestions for similarly-themed food item follow-ups...

Ham Solo
(mr. potato head-like: a honey of a ham in leather pants, vest, and feathery hair)

Stewbacca
(a hairy bowl of soup)
 
Boboli Fett
(pizza crust shell in glorified stormtrooper garb)

Obi-Wan Kabobi(kabob of meat in samurai robe)

Jabba the Nut(one big acorn with scary eyes and a large gaping mouth)

Jar Jar Pickles(a jar of pickles)